Four months ago a Scottish Pub with a devastatingly good whisky selection opened in Brooklyn. I read about it on Gothamist and decided I needed to go the next time I was in town. Amy and her husband and I met there on Thursday (they were there for a wedding; yay timing) and I went back Saturday. I didn't actually have nine whiskies in two days. Not
really. The bartender also gifted one of their amazing little glasses to me when I inquired if I could buy one. They have a really huge selection and Scott will talk your ear off in his lovely Scottish brogue if you want him to or leave you alone if you'd prefer. This is the rest of the backlog.
Benraich 12-year Single Malt Scotch WhiskySpicy, sweet, a little more spicy than sweet but super tasty.
Aberlour 12-year Single Malt Scotch WhiskySo sweet. So smooth. My friend had a hard time not just downing it. I had a hard time not stealing it from her.
Balvenie 14-year Caribbean Cask Single Malt Scotch WhiskyAll that I had hoped for in a rum-cask finished whisky. It's rich and spicy. Amazing.
Littlemill 12-year Single Malt Scotch WhiskyThis is a weird one. It smells like acetone-free nail polish remover but the taste is not unpleasant. There's really a lot going on in there. It's layered, starkly so. The flavors don't blend together gracefully but rather ricochet off each other quickly shifting from one to the next with little warning and little sense. I can't say I don't like it. I can say this is not a drink of comfort.
Bowmore 25-year Single Malt Scotch WhiskyThis is officially the most extravagant whisky I've ever tried. It tasted like a campfire smells but no bite. Very smooth. I can't say I'd have it again at that price but it was worth it to try and share.
Tomatin 12-year Single Malt Scotch WhiskyHoney and vanilla and so very smooth. This one has almost no bite.
The Arran Malt 10-year Single Malt Scotch WhiskyThere's an awful lot going on in here. It smells fruity. There's an after-burn but no smoke or peat that I could discern. It's a different kind of sweet, not the sweet of honey and vanilla and caramel. More the sweet of citrus and melon.
Chivas Brothers Strathisla Pure Highland Malt Scotch Whisky 12-yearInstant favorite. It's like someone made this just for me. The flavor is less intense than caramel. It's almost delicate, like a perfectly roasted marshmallow.
Glenkinchie 12-year Single Malt Scotch WhiskyTastes a bit like carbonized sugar, with an interesting balance of sweet and smokey.